Skip to content

Restore Alyson V2 introduction and maintenance discussion - #1373

Merged
trissim merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
paper/alyson-v2-introduction
Nov 18, 2026
Merged

trissim merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
paper/alyson-v2-introduction

Conversation

@trissim

@trissim trissim commented Nov 18, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

5 coauthor paragraphs restored; 2 concrete examples moved to Discussion

Implements Tristan's new request to use Alyson's actual V2 introduction and retain useful specific points from the old introduction in Discussion. P255 remains completed and unchanged as a historical packet.

Introduction

  • Replace only the current Introduction with the five paragraphs from paper/reviews/alysonnov12/openhcs_V2.docx (original SHA256 a4021945695c43bf8a18cd02bffa9e4c6e89e1fd09cce1c5ff1825a154bd952c).
  • Preserve her prose, including its argument/order, rather than mixing the two introductions.
  • Convert 13 citation-placeholder groups to existing native bibliography keys. Omit misassigned PMID37596471 (napari-imagej) from the napari statement; retain her napari Zenodo DOI through @Napari. Add the existing magicgui documentation citation supporting her graphical-controls clause. No bibliography-record changes.
  • One grammar correction: “Such inspection support” → “Such inspection supports”.

Discussion

Restore the old introduction's concrete dependency-maintenance examples after the existing pipeline-portability paragraph: the pinned napari-n2v compatibility/maintenance notice and the documented Cellpose-SAM/RunCellpose Python3.9 requirement/end-of-life date. Keep their original citations and source links. No duplicate performance/validation discussion.

Preservation and checks

Only paper/manuscript.md changes. Source proof confirms every other byte outside the replaced Introduction and requested Discussion addition is unchanged, including abstract, Methods, Results, captions, back matter and all four generated benchmark spans. Supplement, bibliography, figures, tables, scientific records and shared build library unchanged. All 43 main-text citation identities resolve through existing Pandoc parsing. No scientific rerun or figure regeneration.

Candidate run-20261118T085738-01e5805c: 24 main / 16 supplement / 40 combined pages. All five V2 paragraphs and the Discussion addition verified in actual main/combined DOCX; all citation keys resolve. Embedded images unchanged (6/6/12); all table text and citation identities unchanged. Five combined-table citation display numbers are correctly renumbered after the new introduction; the first literal-number comparison flagged that expected change, and the identity-aware check proves the same targets and prose. All 24 main pages inspected in order, including intro, Discussion, references and figures; complete landscape Table6 inspected on supplement14/combined34. No blank pages. All 21 targeted paper tests pass, exit0,100.93s.

Evidence: owned tmp/alyson-intro-20261118/{source-audit,source-proof,candidate-document-proof}.json and candidate-pages/. Merged as bd0827323ff6f00bdab46591600e6fca615016a6; final run-20261118T090234-7176f843 published current with unchanged observed inputs. All final PDF pages pixel-match the inspected candidate. Native tracked Word accept/reject endpoints reproduce revised/Nov4 original text and images without changing either input. All361 final/P255 and355 Nov4 baseline artifacts hash-verified. Phone delivery completed with7 fresh hashes,45 previous files unchanged and2 Downloads indices; no overwriting. Stem OpenHCS-2026-11-18-Alyson-V2-bd082732. A transient Gaming SSH timeout is retained; original staging completed, then the first extraction succeeded. Final proof tmp/alyson-intro-20261118/final-delivery-proof.json, SHA256 9b29e496a8ab7c41e3849d6371252acaf23e019cc6f7b1d8f25ee828544eca7f. P273 delivery Claimed to independent reviewer MFD; acceptance pending.

@trissim
trissim marked this pull request as ready for review November 18, 2026 09:04
@trissim
trissim merged commit bd08273 into main Nov 18, 2026
3 of 4 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant